This Article  • References  • Full text PDF  • Send to a friend  • Save in My Folder  • Save to citation manager  • Permissions  Citing Articles  • Citation map  • Citing articles on HighWire  • Contact me when this article is cited  Related Content  • Similar articles in JAMA  Social Bookmarking   What's this?

Robert A. Caplan, MD; Karen L. Posner, PhD; Frederick W. Cheney, MD

JAMA. 1991;265(15):1957-1960.

Abstract
Is a permanent injury more likely to elicit a rating of inappropriate care than a temporary injury? To explore this question, we asked 112 practicing anesthesiologists to judge the appropriateness of care in 21 cases involving adverse anesthetic outcomes. The original outcome in each case was classified as either temporary or permanent. The authors then generated a matching alternate case identical to the original in every respect except that a plausible outcome of opposite severity was substituted. The original and alternate cases were randomly divided into two sets and assigned to reviewers who were blind to the intent of the study. The reviewers were asked to rate independently the care in each case as appropriate, less than appropriate, or impossible to judge, based on their personal (implicit) judgment of reasonable and prudent practice. A significant inverse relationship between severity of outcome and judgments of appropriateness of care was observed in 15 (71%) of the 21 matched pairs of cases. Overall, the proportion of ratings for appropriate care decreased by 31 percentage points when the outcome was changed from temporary to permanent and increased by 28 percentage points when the outcome was changed from permanent to temporary. We conclude that knowledge of the severity of outcome can influence a reviewer's judgment of the appropriateness of care.

(JAMA. 1991;265:1957-1960)

Author Affiliations
From the Departments of Anesthesiology, Virginia Mason Medical Center (Dr Caplan) and University of Washington School of Medicine (Drs Posner and Cheney), Seattle. Dr Cheney is the chairman of the Committee on Professional Liability, American Society of Anesthesiologists.

Footnotes
The opinions expressed herein are those of the authors and do not represent the policy of the American Society of Anesthesiologists.

Reprint requests to Anesthesia B2-AN, Virginia Mason Medical Center, PO Box 900, Seattle, WA 98111 (Dr Caplan).

CiteULike    Connotea    Del.icio.us    Digg    Reddit    Technorati    Twitter     What's this?

THIS ARTICLE HAS BEEN CITED BY OTHER ARTICLES

Beyond "see one, do one, teach one": toward a different training paradigm
Rodriguez-Paz et al.
Postgrad. Med. J. 2009;85:244-249.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Beyond "see one, do one, teach one": toward a different training paradigm
Rodriguez-Paz et al.
Qual Saf Health Care 2009;18:63-68.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Factors Associated with Unanticipated Day of Surgery Deaths in Department of Veterans Affairs Hospitals
Bishop et al.
Anesth. Analg. 2008;107:1924-1935.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Where now for expert witnesses?
White
BMJ 2008;337:a1418-a1418.
FULL TEXT  

An epistemology of patient safety research: a framework for study design and interpretation. Part 2. Study design
Brown et al.
Qual Saf Health Care 2008;17:163-169.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

An epistemology of patient safety research: a framework for study design and interpretation. Part 3. End points and measurement
Brown et al.
Qual Saf Health Care 2008;17:170-177.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Health staff perception regarding quality of delivered information to inpatients
Duclos et al.
Int J Qual Health Care 2008;20:13-21.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Patient Decision Aids to Support Clinical Decision Making: Evaluating the Decision or the Outcomes of the Decision
McCaffery et al.
Med Decis Making 2007;27:619-625.
ABSTRACT  

Cervical spine surgery
Hunningher and Calder
Contin Educ Anaesth Crit Care Pain 2007;7:81-84.
FULL TEXT  

Hindsight Bias Among Psychiatrists
LeBourgeois et al.
J Am Acad Psychiatry Law 2007;35:67-73.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Excess mortality caused by medical injury.
Meurer et al.
Ann Fam Med 2006;4:410-416.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Tracking progress in patient safety: an elusive target.
Pronovost et al.
JAMA 2006;296:696-699.
FULL TEXT  

Patient assessments of a hypothetical medical error: effects of health outcome, disclosure, and staff responsiveness.
Cleopas et al.
Qual Saf Health Care 2006;15:136-141.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Diagnostic Error in Internal Medicine
Graber et al.
Arch Intern Med 2005;165:1493-1499.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Fostering Rational Regulation of Patient Safety
Mello et al.
Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 2005;30:375-426.
ABSTRACT  

Safety in the operating theatre - Part 2: Human error and organisational failure
Reason
Qual Saf Health Care 2005;14:56-60.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Outcome Bias
Berlin
Am. J. Roentgenol. 2004;183:557-560.
FULL TEXT  

Adverse events among medical patients after discharge from hospital
Forster et al.
CMAJ 2004;170:345-349.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Psychological contribution to the understanding of adverse events in health care
Parker and Lawton
Qual Saf Health Care 2003;12:453-457.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Hindsight bias, outcome knowledge and adaptive learning
Henriksen and Kaplan
Qual Saf Health Care 2003;12:ii46-50.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

A tragic death: a time to blame or a time to learn?
Runciman and Merry
Qual Saf Health Care 2003;12:321-322.
FULL TEXT  

Error, Blame, and the Law in Health Care--An Antipodean Perspective
Runciman et al.
ANN INTERN MED 2003;138:974-979.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Reliability of the variables in a new set of models that predict outcome after stroke
Weir et al.
J. Neurol. Neurosurg. Psychiatry 2003;74:447-451.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

The Incidence and Severity of Adverse Events Affecting Patients after Discharge from the Hospital
Forster et al.
ANN INTERN MED 2003;138:161-167.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Retrospective case record review: a blunt instrument that needs sharpening
Neale and Woloshynowych
Qual Saf Health Care 2003;12:2-3.
FULL TEXT  

Are Bad Outcomes from Questionable Clinical Decisions Preventable Medical Errors? A Case of Cascade Iatrogenesis
Hofer and Hayward
ANN INTERN MED 2002;137:327-333.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Lessons from the Australian Patient Safety Foundation: setting up a national patient safety surveillance system--is this the right model?
Runciman
Qual Saf Health Care 2002;11:246-251.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Paths to Reducing Medical Injury: Professional Liability and Discipline vs. Patient Safety and the Need for a Third Way
Bovbjerg et al.
J Law Med Ethics 2001;29:369-380.
 

Estimating Hospital Deaths Due to Medical Errors: Preventability Is in the Eye of the Reviewer
Hayward and Hofer
JAMA 2001;286:415-420.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Problems for clinical judgement: 3. Thinking clearly in an emergency
Schull et al.
CMAJ 2001;164:1170-1175.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Bioethics for clinicians: 23. Disclosure of medical error
Hebert et al.
CMAJ 2001;164:509-513.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Institute of Medicine Medical Error Figures Are Not Exaggerated
Leape
JAMA 2000;284:95-97.
FULL TEXT  

Appropriateness of Urgent Referrals by Nurses at a Hospital-Based Pediatric Call Center
Kempe et al.
Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med 2000;154:355-360.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Adverse Sedation Events in Pediatrics: A Critical Incident Analysis of Contributing Factors
Coté et al.
Pediatrics 2000;105:805-814.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Adverse events in health care: issues in measurement
Walshe
Qual Saf Health Care 2000;9:47-52.
FULL TEXT  

Scottish Confidential Inquiry into Asthma Deaths (SCIAD), 1994-6
Bucknall et al.
Thorax 1999;54:978-984.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Suboptimal ward care of critically ill patients
Gorard et al.
BMJ 1999;318:51-51.
FULL TEXT  

Error in Medicine: Legal Impediments to U.S. Reform
Liang
Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 1999;24:27-58.
ABSTRACT  

Chart Review: A Need for Reappraisal
Wu and Ashton
Eval Health Prof 1997;20:146-163.
ABSTRACT  

Validating Quality Indicators: Quality as Relationship Between Structure, Process, and Outcome
Salzer et al.
Eval Rev 1997;21:292-309.
ABSTRACT  

Users' Guides to the Medical Literature: XI. How to Use an Article About a Clinical Utilization Review
Naylor et al.
JAMA 1996;275:1435-1439.
ABSTRACT  

Developing a Cooperative Provider-Based Statewide Peer Review Service: Early Experience
Helms and Wakefield
American Journal of Medical Quality 1996;11:46-50.
ABSTRACT  

Physicians' Mistakes: Will Your Colleagues Offer Support?
Ely
Arch Fam Med 1996;5:76-77.
ABSTRACT  

Linking Process and Outcome of Care in a Continuous Quality Improvement Program for Anesthesia Services
Posner et al.
American Journal of Medical Quality 1994;9:129-137.
ABSTRACT  

The Reliability of Peer Assessments: A Meta-Analysis
Goldman
Eval Health Prof 1994;17:3-21.
ABSTRACT  

Understanding Patients' Decisions: Cognitive and Emotional Perspectives
Redelmeier et al.
JAMA 1993;270:72-76.
ABSTRACT  

The Influence of Standard of Care and Severity of Injury on the Resolution of Medical Malpractice Claims
Taragin et al.
ANN INTERN MED 1992;117:780-784.
ABSTRACT  

Iatrogenic Complications in High-Risk, Elderly Patients
Lefevre et al.
Arch Intern Med 1992;152:2074-2080.
ABSTRACT  

Watching the Doctor-Watchers: How Well Do Peer Review Organization Methods Detect Hospital Care Quality Problems?
Rubin et al.
JAMA 1992;267:2349-2354.
ABSTRACT  

The Reliability of Peer Assessments of Quality of Care
Goldman
JAMA 1992;267:958-960.
ABSTRACT  

Effects of Outcome on Physicians' Judgment of Appropriateness of Care
Woods and Cook
JAMA 1991;266:793-794.
ABSTRACT  

Do Bad Outcomes Mean Substandard Care?
Schroeder and Kabcenell
JAMA 1991;265:1995-1995.
ABSTRACT