This Article  • References  • Full text PDF  • Send to a friend  • Save in My Folder  • Save to citation manager  • Permissions  Citing Articles  • Citation map  • Citing articles on HighWire  • Contact me when this article is cited  Related Content  • Similar articles in JAMA  Social Bookmarking   What's this?

Cost-effectiveness Meets the Rule of Rescue

David C. Hadorn, MD, MA

JAMA. 1991;265(17):2218-2225.

Abstract
The Oregon Health Services Commission recently completed work on its principal charge: creation of a prioritized list of health care services, ranging from the most important to the least important. Oregon's draft priority list was criticized because it seemed to favor minor treatments over lifesaving ones. This reaction reflects a fundamental and irreconcilable conflict between cost-effectiveness analysis and the powerful human proclivity to rescue endangered life: the "Rule of Rescue." Oregon's final priority list was generated without reference to costs and is, therefore, more intuitively sensible than the initial list. However, the utility of the final list is limited by its lack of specificity with regard to conditions and treatments. An alternative approach for setting health care priorities would circumvent the Rule of Rescue by carefully defining necessary indications for treatment. Such an approach might be applied to Oregon's final list in order to achieve better specificity.

(JAMA. 1991;265:2218-2225)

Author Affiliations
From the Department of Social Policy, The RAND Corporation, Santa Monica, Calif, and the Center for Health Ethics and Policy, University of Colorado, Denver.

Footnotes
Reprint requests to Department of Social Policy, The RAND Corporation, 1700 Main St, PO Box 2138, Santa Monica, CA 90406-2138 (Dr Hadorn).

CiteULike    Connotea    Del.icio.us    Digg    Reddit    Technorati    Twitter     What's this?

THIS ARTICLE HAS BEEN CITED BY OTHER ARTICLES

Ethical Challenges In Long-Term Funding For HIV/AIDS
Brock and Wikler
Health Aff (Millwood) 2009;28:1666-1676.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Cost, Effectiveness, and Cost-Effectiveness
Diamond and Kaul
Circ Cardiovasc Qual Outcomes 2009;2:49-54.
FULL TEXT  

The Limits of Cost-Effectiveness Analysis
Weintraub and Cohen
Circ Cardiovasc Qual Outcomes 2009;2:55-58.
FULL TEXT  

Beyond Utilitarianism: A Method for Analyzing Competing Ethical Principles in a Decision Analysis of Liver Transplantation
Volk et al.
Med Decis Making 2008;28:763-772.
ABSTRACT  

The use of cost-effectiveness by the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE): no(t yet an) exemplar of a deliberative process
Schlander
J. Med. Ethics 2008;34:534-539.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Public healthcare resource allocation and the Rule of Rescue
Cookson et al.
J. Med. Ethics 2008;34:540-544.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Media influence on Herceptin subsidization in Australia: application of the rule of rescue?
MacKenzie et al.
JRSM 2008;101:305-312.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Balancing urgency, age and quality of life in organ allocation decisions--what would you do?: a survey
Stahl et al.
J. Med. Ethics 2008;34:109-115.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Economic evaluation of sevelamer in patients with end-stage renal disease
Manns et al.
Nephrol Dial Transplant 2007;22:2867-2878.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Medicare And Cost-Effectiveness Analysis: Time To Ask The Taxpayers
Gold et al.
Health Aff (Millwood) 2007;26:1399-1406.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

How do we evaluate the economics of health care?
Kumar et al.
Eur J Orthod 2006;28:513-519.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Review of NICE's recommendations, 1999-2005.
Raftery
BMJ 2006;332:1266-1268.
FULL TEXT  

Orphan drugs revisited
McCabe et al.
QJM 2006;99:341-345.
FULL TEXT  

NICE discrimination
Rawlins and Dillon
J. Med. Ethics 2005;31:683-684.
FULL TEXT  

Drugs for exceptionally rare diseases: do they deserve special status for funding?
Hughes et al.
QJM 2005;98:829-836.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Orphan drugs and the NHS: should we value rarity?
McCabe et al.
BMJ 2005;331:1016-1019.
FULL TEXT  

Pro/Con Debate: Lung Allocation Should Be Based on Medical Urgency and Transplant Survival and Not on Waiting Time*
Egan and Kotloff
Chest 2005;128:407-415.
FULL TEXT  

Models of Health Care Rationing
Schmidt
Current Sociology 2004;52:969-988.
ABSTRACT  

Real-Time Rationing of Scarce Resources: The Northeast Proton Therapy Center Experience
Jagsi et al.
JCO 2004;22:2246-2250.
FULL TEXT  

Hearts and Minds and Child Restraints in Airplanes
Bishai
Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med 2003;157:953-954.
FULL TEXT  

What Is the Price of Life and Why Doesn't It Increase at the Rate of Inflation?
Ubel et al.
Arch Intern Med 2003;163:1637-1641.
FULL TEXT  

Expensive Conditions
Hay and Druss
Health Aff (Millwood) 2002;21:271-272.
FULL TEXT  

Task Force #2--the cost of prevention: can we afford it? Can we afford not to do it?
Krumholz et al.
J Am Coll Cardiol 2002;40:603-615.
FULL TEXT  

The Most Expensive Medical Conditions In America
Druss et al.
Health Aff (Millwood) 2002;21:105-111.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Can Health Care Costs Be Reduced by Limiting Intensive Care at the End of Life?
LUCE and RUBENFELD
Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med. 2002;165:750-754.
FULL TEXT  

QALYs or quackery? The quagmire of quantifying the cost of breathing
Egan
J. Thorac. Cardiovasc. Surg. 2002;123:406-408.
FULL TEXT  

Physicians' Attitudes toward Health Care Rationing
Perneger et al.
Med Decis Making 2002;22:65-70.
ABSTRACT  

Waiting in the NHS, Part 2: a change of prescription
Derrett et al.
JRSM 2002;95:280-283.
FULL TEXT  

Managing public payment for high-cost, high-benefit treatment: enzyme replacement therapy for Gaucher's disease in Ontario
Clarke et al.
CMAJ 2001;165:595-596.
FULL TEXT  

Revising a Priority List Based on Cost-Effectiveness: The Role of the Prominence Effect and Distorted Utility Judgments
Baron and Ubel
Med Decis Making 2001;21:278-287.
ABSTRACT  

The End of Managed Care
Robinson
JAMA 2001;285:2622-2628.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Preference for Equity As a Framing Effect
Ubel et al.
Med Decis Making 2001;21:180-189.
ABSTRACT  

Principles of justice in health care rationing
Cookson and Dolan
J. Med. Ethics 2000;26:323-329.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Quality of Life: Erosions and Opportunities Under Managed Care
Morreim
J Law Med Ethics 2000;28:144-158.
 

Impact of Oregon's Priority List on Medicaid Beneficiaries
Mitchell and Bentley
Med Care Res Rev 2000;57:216-234.
ABSTRACT  

The Need for Perspective in Evidence-Based Medicine
Woolf
JAMA 1999;282:2358-2365.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Tragic choices in health care: lessons from the Child B case
Ham
BMJ 1999;319:1258-1261.
FULL TEXT  

Resource Utilization in Liver Transplantation: Effects of Patient Characteristics and Clinical Practice
Showstack et al.
JAMA 1999;281:1381-1386.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

The Which-Hunt:Assembling Health Technologies for Assessment and Rationing
Giacomini
Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 1999;24:715-758.
ABSTRACT  

Clinical and Nonclinical Predictors of the Cost of Coronary Bypass Surgery: Potential Effects on Health Care Delivery and Reimbursement
Denton et al.
Arch Intern Med 1998;158:886-891.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Health Values of Hospitalized Patients 80 Years or Older
Tsevat et al.
JAMA 1998;279:371-375.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

Fair Allocation of Intensive Care Unit Resources
Am. J. Respir. Crit. Care Med. 1997;156:1282-1301.
FULL TEXT  

The Role of Cost-effectiveness Analysis in Health and Medicine
Russell et al.
JAMA 1996;276:1172-1177.
ABSTRACT  

Assigning Values to Intermediate Health States for Cost-Utility Analysis: Theory and Practice
Cohen
Med Decis Making 1996;16:376-385.
ABSTRACT  

Oregon's Medicaid Ranking and Cost- Effectiveness: Is There Any Relationship?
Tengs et al.
Med Decis Making 1996;16:99-107.
ABSTRACT  

Individual Utilities Are Inconsistent with Rationing Choices: A Partial Explanation of Why Oregon's Cost-Effectiveness List Failed
Ubel et al.
Med Decis Making 1996;16:108-116.
ABSTRACT  

The Oregon Priority-setting Exercise: Cost-Effectiveness and the Rule of Rescue, Revisited
Hadorn
Med Decis Making 1996;16:117-119.
 

Cost-Effectiveness Analysis in a Setting of Budget Constraints -- Is It Equitable?
Ubel et al.
NEJM 1996;334:1174-1177.
ABSTRACT | FULL TEXT  

The Unbearable Rightness of Bedside Rationing: Physician Duties in a Climate of Cost Containment
Ubel and Arnold
Arch Intern Med 1995;155:1837-1842.
ABSTRACT  

The Oregonian ICU: Multi-Tiered Monetarized Morality in Health Insurance Law
Rie
J Law Med Ethics 1995;23:149-166.
 

Comparison of Time-tradeoff Utilities and Rating Scale Values of Cancer Patients and Their Relatives: Evidence for a Possible Plateau Relationship
O'Leary et al.
Med Decis Making 1995;15:132-137.
ABSTRACT  

Cost and Outcome of Intensive Care for Patients With AIDS, Pneumocystis carinii Pneumonia, and Severe Respiratory Failure
Wachter et al.
JAMA 1995;273:230-235.
ABSTRACT  

When Should Preventive Treatment Be Paid for by Health Insurance?
Annas
NEJM 1994;331:1027-1030.
FULL TEXT  

United States Health Care System Reform: An Era of Shared Sacrifice and Responsibility Begins
Lundberg
JAMA 1994;271:1530-1533.
ABSTRACT  

Ethical Foundations of the Clinton Administration's Proposed Health Care System
Brock and Daniels
JAMA 1994;271:1189-1196.
ABSTRACT  

Controversies in Treatment: How can hospitals ration drugs? Drug rationing in a teaching hospital: a method to assign priorities
Bochner et al.
BMJ 1994;308:901-905.
FULL TEXT  

Setting Limits in Clinical Medicine
Murphy et al.
Arch Intern Med 1994;154:505-512.
ABSTRACT  

New Do-Not-Resuscitate Policies: A First Step in Cost Control
Murphy and Finucane
Arch Intern Med 1993;153:1641-1648.
ABSTRACT  

Will the Phoenix Rise, and Where Should She Go?: The Women's Health Agenda
HAFNER-EATON
American Behavioral Scientist 1993;36:841-856.
ABSTRACT  

The Problem of Discrimination in Health Care Priority Setting
Hadorn
JAMA 1992;268:1454-1459.
ABSTRACT  

The High-Risk Liver Allograft Recipient: Should Allocation Policy Consider Outcome?
Delmonico et al.
Arch Surg 1992;127:579-584.
ABSTRACT  

Efficacy and Cost-effectiveness of Autologous Bone Marrow Transplantation in Metastatic Breast Cancer: Estimates Using Decision Analysis While Awaiting Clinical Trial Results
Hillner et al.
JAMA 1992;267:2055-2061.
ABSTRACT  

Prioritizing Oregon's Hospital Resources: An Example Based on Variations in Discretionary Medical Utilization
Fisher et al.
JAMA 1992;267:1925-1931.
ABSTRACT  

Cost-effectiveness Analysis: A Conversation With My Father
Eddy
JAMA 1992;267:1669-1675.
ABSTRACT  

The Health Care Resource Allocation Debate: Defining Our Terms
Hadorn and Brook
JAMA 1991;266:3328-3331.
ABSTRACT  

Oregon's Methods: Did Cost-effectiveness Analysis Fail?
Eddy
JAMA 1991;266:2135-2141.
 

Setting Health Care Priorities in Oregon
Gillette
JAMA 1991;266:1080-1080.
ABSTRACT  

Setting Health Care Priorities in Oregon
MacLean
JAMA 1991;266:1080-1081.
ABSTRACT  

What's Going on in Oregon?
Eddy
JAMA 1991;266:417-420.
 

Oregon's Bold Medicaid Initiative
Stason
JAMA 1991;265:2237-2238.
ABSTRACT