Clinical and Radiographic Correlates of Primary and Reactivation Tuberculosis
A Molecular Epidemiology Study
- Elvin Geng, MD, MPH;
- Barry Kreiswirth, PhD;
- Joe Burzynski, MD, MPH;
- Neil W. Schluger, MD
- Author Affiliations: College of Physicians and Surgeons (Drs Geng and Schluger) and Mailman School of Public Health (Dr Schluger), Columbia University, New York, NY; Public Health Research Institute, Newark, NJ (Dr Kreiswirth); and New York City Department of Health Tuberculosis Control Program, New York (Dr Burzynski).
- Corresponding Author: Neil W. Schluger, MD, Division of Pulmonary, Allergy, and Critical Care Medicine, Columbia University Medical Center, 630 W 168th St PH-8 East, New York, NY 10032 (ns311{at}columbia.edu).
Abstract
Context The traditional teaching that pulmonary tuberculosis characterized by lymphadenopathy, effusions, and lower or mid lung zone infiltrates on chest radiography represents “primary” disease from recently acquired infection, whereas upper lobe infiltrates and cavities represent secondary or reactivation disease acquired in the more distant past, is not based on well-established clinical evidence. Furthermore, it is not known whether the atypical radiograph common in human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)–associated tuberculosis is due to a preponderance of primary progressive disease or altered immunity.
Objective To analyze the relationship between recently acquired and remotely acquired pulmonary tuberculosis, clinical and demographic variables, and radiographic features by using molecular fingerprinting and conventional epidemiology.
Design, Setting, and Population A retrospective, hospital-based series of 456 patients treated at a New York City medical center between 1990 and 1999. Eligible patients had to have had at least 1 positive respiratory culture for Mycobacterium tuberculosis and available radiographic data.
Main Outcome Measures Radiographic appearance as measured by the presence or absence of 6 features: upper lobe infiltrate, cavitary lesion, adenopathy, effusions, lower or mid lung zone infiltrate, and miliary pattern. Radiographs were considered typical if they had an upper lobe infiltrate or cavity whether or not other features were present. Atypical radiographs were those that had adenopathy, effusion, or mid lower lung zone infiltrates or had none of the above features.
Results Human immunodeficiency virus infection was most commonly associated with an atypical radiographic appearance on chest radiograph with an odds ratio of 0.20 (95% confidence interval, 0.13-0.31). Although a clustered fingerprint, representing recently acquired disease, was associated with typical radiograph in univariate analysis (odds ratio, 0.68; 95% confidence interval, 0.47-0.99), the association was lost when adjusted for HIV status.
Conclusions Time from acquisition of infection to development of clinical disease does not reliably predict the radiographic appearance of tuberculosis. Human immunodeficiency virus status, a probable surrogate for the integrity of the host immune response, is the only independent predictor of radiographic appearance. The altered radiographic appearance of pulmonary tuberculosis in HIV is due to altered immunity rather than recent acquisition of infection and progression to active disease.
